Best QOTSA line-up ?

jason s · Administrator

Best QOTSA line-up ?

elchicano · Simple Exploding..Human

One of my all time favorite bands.
Josh,Nick,Gene,Mark.
:(
(I've been listening to "In the Fade" for about an hour now).

Madeline · Simple Exploding..Human

Josh / Nick / Mark / Dave Grohl

Probably because thats when i really got into them.
Old good memories

Mike · Like An A-Bomb

Second one. Guess it's my fav album:D
I only need Troy there and it would be perfect. For live the best was: Mark, Josh, Nick, Troy, Joey

Wired Ape · Simple Exploding..Human

Grohl. It has Grohl. That's all.

mitchell · Basket Case

Rated R for the win.

Laura · Simple Exploding..Human

SFTD

DonDFA1972 · Simple Exploding..Human

they are all such different incarnations... they are all awesome...

Hans down SFTD.

But mos Def anything with Mark "big daddy" Lanegan.

jkpunk · Jonny Cake Y'all

Rated R period for me.
That line up is I guess what I think is the real qotsa line up in my head.
Joey is awesome though.

elchicano · Simple Exploding..Human

DonDFA1972 wrote:

they are all such different incarnations... they are all awesome...

Hans down SFTD.

But mos Def anything with Mark "big daddy" Lanegan.

elchicano · Simple Exploding..Human

jkpunk wrote:

Rated R period for me.
That line up is I guess what I think is the real qotsa line up in my head.
Joey is awesome though.

Ditto.

mitchell · Basket Case

I reckon the Rated R line-up with Lanegan is the best live one, too. Gene is super tight on drums.

Exhibit A.

Laura · Simple Exploding..Human

The best of Grohl!

-- Edited by Laura at 14:40, 2008-06-24

elchicano · Simple Exploding..Human

The baddest mothe rfu cker on vox and bass!!![youtube=http://youtube.com/watch?v=SMd6CcX7yPA]

-- Edited by elchicano at 19:41, 2008-06-24

Vince Noir · Mod Wolf

*waits for someone to put post-2004 lineups down*

Yeah, it has to be SFTD for me. Grohl is my favourite drummer. He should never ever have moved to the front of the band when he's that good. If he was a mediocre drummer, I would've understood. But yeah, also Mark Lanegan can make me wet and all he has to do is sing. He has the same effect on me that I'm sure Isaac Hayes had on the ladies. And obviously, you can't go past the chemistry between Nick and Josh.